How to Overcome Frighteningly Inconsistent Hiring Practices

December 12, 2022


Hiring practices have become increasingly inconsistent in recent years, leading to confusion and frustration among job seekers and employers alike. To ensure that the hiring process is fair and efficient, companies must be aware of the challenges arising from inconsistent hiring practices and develop strategies to overcome them.  

Would you hear the same interview questions being asked if you were to listen to a dozen job interviews conducted by your company? Would the interviews continue in the same order as they were conducted? Would managers always use the same criteria when evaluating candidates?  

According to the survey titled “The Worker Shortage Is Partially Self-Inflicted,” 62% of HR executives say that their company’s recruiting managers are inconsistent in evaluating candidates for open positions. In addition, 68% of respondents believe that their company’s hiring supervisors analyze applicants in a manner that needs to be more consistent.  

This article will discuss the causes of inconsistent hiring practices and provide strategies that employers and job seekers can use to ensure a successful and consistent recruiting process.  


6 Ways to Overcome Operational Hiring Challenges  

It is essential to commit to recruiting operations, the primary goal of which should be the development of the most efficient hiring methods to improve ROI and eliminate pain points. If there are holes in your recruiting pipeline, fixing them will allow your team to concentrate on locating and recruiting the best candidates.  

Recruiters can discover pain areas and prevail over common operational hiring issues using top strategies. 

         1. Make the mental shift from being reactive to proactive in your approach. 

Traditionally, talent acquisition teams have adopted a reactive approach to the hiring process. This means that they only source candidates and fill open positions when it is necessary to do so. This technique results in longer than necessary recruiting timeframes and varying experiences for job candidates. Building and maintaining a talent pipeline of people who may be suitable for future opportunities is a good way to get a leg up on the competition and ensure you remain one step ahead of the curve. Implementing a proactive recruiting strategy means getting ready to meet hiring demands even before a position becomes available. You’ll then be able to find the best applicants to complete requisitions when you have access to engaged talent.  

2. Develop an Experience That Is Consistent Across All Candidates 

A candidate’s interaction with your organization is a deciding factor in their decision to accept your offer; also, prospects today have heightened expectations regarding how quickly the recruiting process should be completed. It may be difficult to execute a uniform interview procedure if the candidate experience is disconnected, which may also contribute to a decline in the number of applicants.  

To get around this typical obstacle, you should devise a uniform interview and evaluation procedure that provides each applicant with the same experience. Train every hiring team member on the best techniques for conducting interviews and ensure that every candidate is evaluated based on the same criteria. Utilize recruiting software to help speed up the feedback collection process. It is important to keep job applicants updated on their status during the selection process so that they are aware of where they stand.   

If you provide a positive experience for candidates, you can be assured that every applicant will leave your organization as a brand ambassador. 

3. Increase The Employee Engagement and Retain The Best Talent

In most cases, the most cost-effective hires are made through employee referrals. However, your pipeline will remain full of candidates if you plan to motivate current team members to refer others in their network for available opportunities. Develop a talent-spotting mentality among all your staff members so that they can all contribute to the hiring process.  

Sharing available opportunities regularly will help the employees keep themselves up to date on the company’s recruiting needs. Utilize tools designed for employee referrals to make it simpler for employees to refer friends and co-workers, track their progress in the hiring process, and earn rewards. Encourage employees to make referrals by holding a friendly competition amongst their co-workers to see who can refer the most candidates.

4. Utilize Recruiting Metrics to Identify Areas Where Improvements Can Be Made 

Do members of your recruiting team respond with “That’s the way it’s always been done” when you inquire about the rationale behind a particular hiring practice by the company? The fact that something has been done in a certain way for a long time does not automatically make it the method of choice.  

Include data in the recruiting process so that decisions may be made strategically based on crucial indicators rather than relying on hiring practices that have been done in the past. Run reports using recruitment analytics software to gain an understanding of metrics at each stage of the recruiting process. Analyze procedures to determine where improvements are needed by using key performance indicators (KPIs) such as application completion rate, acceptance rate, and time-to-hire, and find opportunities to optimize the hiring pipeline.  

5. Collect Feedback from Applicants as well as Hiring Managers 

The greatest method to enhance recruitment operations is to collect feedback from candidates and recruiting managers since they are the ones who come into contact with your hiring process the most. Inquire of potential candidates’ opinions regarding the length of the hiring process, the modes of communication, and their experiences in general. They may identify a problem that you should have thought about.  

Collect feedback from hiring managers at the end of each recruitment cycle to assess their level of contentment with the hiring process, the quality of applicants, and the working relationship between recruiters and recruiting managers. Put this input to use to improve the hiring process and rid yourself of reoccurring problems.  

6. Merge the Technologies Used in Recruiting 

In no circumstance can difficulties in hiring be attributable to recruiting technology. Recruiting new employees should be facilitated rather than hampered by technological solutions. Suppose several technological platforms cause recruiters to work more slowly or make training more difficult. In that case, consider deploying talent acquisition software to centralize all your recruiting efforts in one location. With a centralized database, information will never be lost due to recruiter churn. Furthermore, openness means that any recruiter can fill in for another recruiter when the latter is absent from the office. You may build a targeted and effective recruiting strategy by streamlining your talent operations with the appropriate technologies.  

The Final Word  

Frighteningly inconsistent hiring practices can lead to confusion and frustration among job seekers and employers. To ensure that the recruiting process is fair and efficient, companies must be aware of the challenges arising from inconsistent hiring practices and develop strategies to overcome them. This article has discussed the causes of inconsistent hiring practices and provided strategies that employers and job seekers can use to ensure a successful and consistent hiring process. 

Here’s How Yaksha Has Helped Organisations Like Yours

As a tech HR and L&D professional, you are expected to always keep an eye on the current and upcoming trends of L&D and tech

Want To See Yaksha In Action?